Germany - Ukraine

Europe: UEFA Nations League
Germany L. Sané (23), T. Werner (33), T. Werner (64)
Red Bull Arena3-1
Ukraine R. Yaremchuk (12)

"No 'Category One Patient'":
Leipzig officials disclose why Germany-Ukraine was cleared

By Peter Vice

After the fact, officials in Leipzig's public health department explained why they opted to allow Saturday's UEFA Nations League fixture to proceed. 

Article image

Whether or not the ball would roll in Leipzig on Saturday remained in doubt even a scant few hours before kickoff. The ultimate decision to allow the fixture to be played came from local health authorities, who went public with their reasoning on Sunday morning.

Five positive COVID tests (four players, one staff member) among the Ukrainian ranks presented the Leipzig health department with a dilemma. Local administrators were well within their legal rights to order the entire team into quarantine, thereby ensuring the cancellation of the match.

There exists some understandable speculation that the health department might have felt unduly pressured to green light the match, lest the German Nationalmannschaft be forced to forfeit the points. The current UEFA regulations do, in fact, place authorities in such a difficult position.

If a match is outright cancelled, the UEFA control committee inherits the right to assign a score to the match. In principle, the hosting nation can lose both the points and have their group goal differential adversely affected. This occurs when a locale or national association is deemed "responsible" for the fixture's abrogation.

The case of the Norwegian national team shall provide an interesting case study in how this might work. Norwegian health authorities ordered the entire team into quarantine following one positive test on Saturday. The team now cannot travel to Bucharest for a scheduled Sunday evening encounter against Romania. UEFA will now decide if Norway forfeits points and goals.

Perhaps in an effort to get ahead of such speculation, the Leipzig health department insisted that their decision was based on scientific contract tracing protocols. City spokesperson Matthias Hasberg pointed out that the decision was based on relevant conversations with the Ukrainian national team, adding "a health department is not a police force".

According to Hasberg, detailed contact tracing interviews revealed that there was no "Category One Patient" in the visiting team. Such a crucial classification is defined as an infected actor who has spent at least 15 minutes in close contact with other team members.

This preventative measure stems the possibility of larger outbreaks within a group and is indeed the reason why positive tests within a team need not always lead to match postponements.

Hasberg emphasized that, after thorough questioning, there was no reason to doubt the information supplied by the visiting team. "We rely on what the team tells us," he noted.

1Manuel Neuer (C)
4Matthias Ginter
15Niklas Süle
16Antonio Rüdiger
13Philipp Max
18Leon Goretzka
2Robin Koch
21İlkay Gündoğan
19Leroy Sané ↩86
20Serge Gnabry
9Timo Werner ↩76
12Bernd Leno
22Kevin Trapp
10Julian Brandt ↪76
11L. Waldschmidt ↪86
3Felix Uduokhai
5Jonathan Tah
14Benjamin Henrichs
17Niklas Stark
6Florian Neuhaus
7Nadiem Amiri
23Mahmoud Dahoud
12Andriy Pyatov (C)
15Yukhym Konoplia
3Illia Zabarnyi
22Mykola Matviyenko
2Eduard Sobol
8Ruslan Malinovskiy
6Taras Stepanenko ↩69
17Oleksandr Zinchenko ↩86
11Marlos Romero Bonfim
9Roman Yaremchuk ↩75
19Oleksandr Zubkov ↩74
1Yury Pankiv
23Andriy Lunin
10Júnior Moraes ↪75
4Sergiy Krivtsov
5Yevgen Cheberko
20Valerii Bondar
21Bogdan Mykhaylichenko ↪74
14Ihor Kharatin ↪86
18Evgeny Makarenko ↪69

Bundesliga News

Fantasy Football

Tactics Talk

Editor's picks


Turn back time